The expense of Mother`s day cards, international calls home, nursing home fees, funeral untaker charges-all unecessary expenses according to the subect of the following article.
Read on:
Just ditch those difficult parents
Tuesday April 18th 2006
Controversial agony aunt Dr Laura’s advice on relations you don’t get on with is to sever ties - and she set an example with her own mother. CHRIS AYRES meets her
The headline in the Los Angeles Times read ‘Mother of Dr Laura Found Dead’. It was the week before Christmas in 2002. At first glance the story seemed unremarkable: a personal tragedy for the blonde, conservative radio host but not much else.
But the facts of the case got stranger as you read on. Yolanda Schlessinger, a 77-year-old Italian Catholic, had died in her apartment, where her body had remained undiscovered for about four months.
More curious still were the details that emerged of the 20-year silence between the dead woman and her daughter, Dr Laura, a converted Orthodox Jewish agony aunt who, at the time, had the second most popular radio show in America, after Rush Limbaugh.
Although Dr Laura had previously talked about her estranged mother on air, the news came as a shock. A few asked the question on everyone’s mind: how could Dr Laura possibly be qualified to offer advice on motherhood to 12 million listeners?
Today, four years after Yolanda Schlessinger’s body was discovered, Dr Laura wants to answer that question with a self-help book: Bad Childhood, Good Life. A more appropriate title might have been They F**k You Up, Your Mum and Dad, in homage to Philip Larkin’s This be the Verse, although Dr Laura would probably not condone such language.
Neither would she agree with Larkin’s misanthropic conclusion: that parents pass down their problems to their children, so “don’t have any kids yourself”. Dr Laura (59) is famous for introducing herself as “my kid’s mom”. Her only child, Deryk, serves in the armed forces. Dr Laura boasts that her brand of 1950s-era moral philosophy - mothers should stay at home; those who hire nannies or use day-care services are harming their children - has produced the ideal result.
“I have a 20-year-old son who, when he’s not training for 10 days in the wild, calls me every day,” she likes to say.
Bad Childhood’s tone is perhaps best sampled in the postscript, where Dr Laura complains: “I always took (my late mother) on my vacations and bought her lovely gifts even when I had a modest income. She was never grateful and would always find something to criticise.”
Dr Laura goes on to blame her mother for causing their estrangement - saying that she walked out of a receptionist’s job at her counselling clinic after refusing to take a typing class. And when Dr Laura describes the day that she heard about her mother’s Scrooge-like death, she informs the reader: “Apparently she had no friends and none of her neighbours were close, so nobody even noticed! How sad.”
This flippancy soon morphs into full-blown celebrity narcissism. “The horrendous part of all this is how the media, because I am a ‘celebrity’, handled this event,” Dr Laura concludes. “My mother (caused me) pain even after death!”
I drove to meet Dr Laura at her home on the clifftops of Santa Barbara, a seaside town a couple of hours north of Los Angeles. She shares the place with her second husband, Lewis Bishop, who was previously married with dependent children - one of the many moral U-turns in Dr Laura’s life that attracts claims of hypocrisy.
She counters with one of her many moral tabloidisms: “Do what I say, not what I did.”
From the moment Dr Laura padded into the reception room barefoot, dressed in a baby-pink tracksuit, she was brittle, defensive.
Within a few minutes she had offered more criticism of her late mother, accusing her of lacking discipline. So I asked for the real reason why they fell out.
“I didn’t fall out with my mother,” she replied, with Clintonian precision. “When it was clear that my career was taking off, I needed her to learn typing. She said ‘If I’m going to take any class, it’ll be ceramics’. I said ‘Well, you can take that too, but I really need you to take a typing class’ and she packed her bags and refused to talk to me ever again, no matter what contact we tried to make.
Dr Laura explained that her family’s problems went back much farther than the typing dispute. Her mother, who looked like Sophia Loren, was a war bride from Italy who married a second lieutenant in the US Army after the American liberation. After a shotgun wedding in Italy, the couple returned to the US, where Monroe Schlessinger’s Jewish family began a campaign against the ’shiksa’ - the non-Jewish wife. Things were not easy for Dr Laura’s mother, whose older sister had been killed by the Nazis for joining the Resistance.
Dr Laura says: “My family was not in any way loving: the tension, the anger, the hostility, the dissension, the lack of love and affection, all had its impact. Up until the age of 13 I thought my name was ’stupid’, or ‘lazy’, because that’s what my father told me I was.”
So, how should people handle their bad childhoods?
Dr Laura spits at the pop-psychology notion of closure with the same long-range ferocity that she spits at feminists and lefties, telling readers that people who claim to have found closure are kidding themselves.
“There is no such thing as history being erased or made entirely powerless.”
Instead, she argues for “resilience”: being willing to identify situations that make you act out your ‘Bad Childhood’, change your behaviour and move on.
Unsurprisingly, Dr Laura often promotes excommunication as an effective way to neutralise a troublesome parent. “The good news I have for you is that giving up hope is one of the healthiest, most life-affirming things you could do for yourself!” she writes. “That is, of course, if you follow my two-step plan: accept, and don’t pout.”
“I don’t like to sit and argue,” she replied. “I’ve heard all points of view. If we argue about something, I’m simply trying to muscle you into my way of thinking, and you are muscling me into your way of thinking. I prefer to spend my time helping people.”
I told Dr Laura that I learnt things by arguing with people. “Well, you’re a man of few convictions,” she replied. It was time to leave.
On the way out, she became friendlier and tried to explain why she was so defensive. “If you go on the internet and look up Charles Manson and Hitler, you’ll find fan clubs. You do the same thing for me, you’ll find several thousand hate groups. And all I’m trying to do is to get people to do the right thing by their children and to lead decent lives.”
I dismissed this as another bout of narcissism, but then ran a search for Dr Laura on Google when I got home and discovered an absurd ‘Stop Dr Laura’ website and another page full of explicitly pornographic photographs of her, taken several decades ago.
Perhaps she had a point: a lot of people really hate her. To me, her moral certainty is infuriating but her willingness to argue the exact opposite of the politically correct norm is to be admired. Even to my relatively liberal ears, many of her theories on child care are commonsensical.
Bad childhood, good life? A wealthy life for Dr Laura, certainly, but perhaps not such a happy one. Larkin, the old misery, was dead right: they f*** you up, your mum and dad.
‘Bad Childhood, Good Life’ by Laura Schlessinger is published by Harper Collins, (」7.99).